3.1.1 Harare It was good news for Civil Society Organisations following the High Court ruling which nullified Harare Provincial Development Coordinator, Tafadzwa Muguti's decision to ban some non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) after they defied submitting their work plans as he had directed them to do. In an urgent chamber application filed on 3 August, Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum and Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition Trust, both coalitions of NGOs argued the directive was unconstitutional as Muguti has no mandate dealing with NGOs. Muguti, Minister of State for Provincial Affairs and Devolution Harare Metropolitan Province, Local Government, Home Affairs, Public Service ministers were all cited as respondents. In its ruling handed down on 17 September , the High Court said the applicants had proved a prima facie case establishing that their constitutional rights had been violated by Muguti's directive. In a disturbing development, a Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) leaked memo, revealed that the supposedly independent body was waiting for instructions from unnamed authorities for it to include the main opposition, MDC Alliance, in the commission’s consultative processes for stakeholders. ZEC spokesperson Commissioner Joyce Kazembe confirmed to NewsDay that the MDC Alliance was not invited to the critical meetings because the matter over the ownership of the name MDC Alliance was still to be resolved at the courts. “We did not extend our invitation to MDC Alliance to be part of a stakeholder meeting because the matter regarding the name MDC Alliance is still before the courts,” she told NewsDay. Ironically, there is no legal wrangle before the courts over the MDC Alliance name. Following the leaked memo, a youth leader in the MDC Alliance Denford Ngadziore who had gone to attempt to attend the ZEC meeting, and nine journalists who were covering the event, were arrested on 30 September. This shows the extent to which there is collusion between the state and the ruling Zanu PF, whose leadership has openly declared they ‘own’ every institution in the country. President Emmerson Mnangagwa is on record bragging about how the party owns the police, the Commissions, the army and virtually every institution. Meanwhile, Zanu PF’s chairperson for Harare province Godwills Masimirembwa had a chair thrown at him during preparations for chaotic district elections held on 24 September court heard. Masimirembwa’s deputy Godwin Gomwe appeared in court charged with assault over the incident. Gomwe allegedly accused Masimirembwa of creating fictitious party districts to facilitate the rigging of internal elections in favour of Harare’s minister of state, Oliver Chidau, in forthcoming Zanu PF provincial elections. Gomwe is alleged to have shouted: ”Ndirikuda kukum*m*sa Masimirembwa. Urikuda kuriga maelections uchiitira Chidau kuti aite chairman. Ndoda kukuputitsa zidumbu iroro (I will pummel you Masimirembwa. You want to rig elections for Chidau so that he becomes chairman. I will pop that large belly).”

Select target paragraph3